View unanswered posts | View active topics
|
Page 1 of 2
|
[ 19 posts ] |
|
| Author |
Message |
|
hegyak
|
Post subject: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 01:21 |
|
| I live here Три раза сломал клаву :) |
 |
Joined: Monday, 31 Mar 2008, 19:17 Posts: 6156 Location: Being smug somewhere fun
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
ChrisTX
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 04:30 |
|
| A+ |
 |
Joined: Wednesday, 26 Dec 2007, 00:42 Posts: 7317
|
hegyak wrote: You make money, you get sued. Way to go Copyright system! a) Patent law != copyright b) There's nothing you could really do to improve the situation. The patent itself could be a case of prior art here. If not, then it's an absolutely legal way of asserting your intellectual property. Uniloc is a known patent troll. Yes, but how would you outlaw patent trolls? The problem is that you cannot live without patents. If you try to strengthen the requirements for patent trolls, that will simply create new loopholes. It is pretty likely actually that Uniloc can win this case. They already vindicated in a few other high-profile suits. Oh wait, nobody cared about Microsoft being sued for $338 million over the same shitty patent but the entire internet goes bottom up if Mojang gets sued.
_________________ Game Industry Guardian (1K+).
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
hegyak
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 05:28 |
|
| I live here Три раза сломал клаву :) |
 |
Joined: Monday, 31 Mar 2008, 19:17 Posts: 6156 Location: Being smug somewhere fun
|
|
Nothing like trolls to wreck your day.
Where's my Fire and Acid?
_________________ The phrase "Login to http://www.clue.org and issue the GET command" springs to mind...  I moderated this forum.
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
Mr.Deviance
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 10:40 |
|
| Administrator |
 |
Joined: Thursday, 09 Oct 2003, 00:45 Posts: 2763 Location: Admin's watchtower
|
|
The only reason why I'm not here laughing my ass off and publicly exposing my wish to see him bankrupt, is because he donated money to carmageddon reincarnation's kickstarter, which is very important to me! So, I hope he won't go bankrupt very soon. But you have to admit that for one fat ass bearded fag, to make so much money so fast from so little, does tend to upset some people, especially jews. My best guess is that some jewish corporation that specializes in avoiding the law through legislation holes is going to rape his ass sooner or later. He's just one guy. The more money he makes, the more dangerous it becomes to keep them safe from shit like this. After you reach one critical sum of $1 million, scumbags start noticing you and then if you go beyond the first million, they start noticing you more and more. Last I checked, Notch made at least over $10 million.
I remember that Garry Newman also started having problems like this, after he got his first serious money from gmod sales.
_________________ 
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
MaxxPaynn
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 10:54 |
|
Joined: Sunday, 15 Jul 2012, 12:29 Posts: 17
|
Mr.Deviance wrote: The only reason why I'm not here laughing my ass off and publicly exposing my wish to see him bankrupt, is because he donated money to carmageddon reincarnation's kickstarter, which is very important to me! So, I hope he won't go bankrupt very soon. But you have to admit that for one fat ass bearded fag, to make so much money so fast from so little, does tend to upset some people, especially jews. My best guess is that some jewish corporation that specializes in avoiding the law through legislation holes is going to rape his ass sooner or later. He's just one guy. The more money he makes, the more dangerous it becomes to keep them safe from shit like this. After you reach one critical sum of $1 million, scumbags start noticing you and then if you go beyond the first million, they start noticing you more and more. Last I checked, Notch made at least over $10 million.
I remember that Garry Newman also started having problems like this, after he got his first serious money from gmod sales. True thing, there have allways been internet scumbags who think that if you earn more then $1 million you are some type of a hacker or bank robber...
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
Mr.Deviance
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 11:10 |
|
| Administrator |
 |
Joined: Thursday, 09 Oct 2003, 00:45 Posts: 2763 Location: Admin's watchtower
|
MaxxPaynn wrote: True thing, there have allways been internet scumbags who think that if you earn more then $1 million you are some type of a hacker or bank robber... I was not talking about internet here. The mafia groups don't give a shit about the internet. Once you make such sums of money without stealing them, it doesn't matter if you exist online or not. You will be sued one way or the other.
_________________ 
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
ChrisTX
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 15:57 |
|
| A+ |
 |
Joined: Wednesday, 26 Dec 2007, 00:42 Posts: 7317
|
Mr.Deviance wrote: After you reach one critical sum of $1 million, scumbags start noticing you and then if you go beyond the first million, they start noticing you more and more. Last I checked, Notch made at least over $10 million.
I remember that Garry Newman also started having problems like this, after he got his first serious money from gmod sales. It's a patent troll, such companies live off using their assets either gained through purchased or by a period of success within their actual business that has passed by (this is the case of Uniloc - they sold activation systems for try'n'buy software). Mojang is sued for patent infringement in Minecraft Pocket Edition. This wouldn't be the first successful app maker being sued and it's not going to be the last one either. Actually, Mojang was sued together with a whole bunch of companies: [quote name="Wikipedia"]Electronic Arts, citing Bejeweled 2 as an infringement upon their patents on Android devices. Uniloc also filed complaints for infringing the same patent against companies including: Distinctive Developments, Full Fat Productions, Gameloft, Halfbrick Studios, Laminar Research, Madfinger Games, Polarbit and Square Enix.[/quote] Still, the internet does not care about anything but "Omg, Minecraft! Can't be!". Well, nobody cares that EA was sued* or that the Fruit Ninja creator Halfbrick Studio was sued also. They simply evaluate where they can press money for their patents and judge based on ROI. That's business. * Because I know this will be said: EA owns Bejeweled because they purchased PopCap games. If they hadn't, Uniloc had sued an indie studio which PopCap was before the purchase.
_________________ Game Industry Guardian (1K+).
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
MaxxPaynn
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 17:31 |
|
Joined: Sunday, 15 Jul 2012, 12:29 Posts: 17
|
Mr.Deviance wrote: MaxxPaynn wrote: True thing, there have allways been internet scumbags who think that if you earn more then $1 million you are some type of a hacker or bank robber... I was not talking about internet here. The mafia groups don't give a shit about the internet. Once you make such sums of money without stealing them, it doesn't matter if you exist online or not. You will be sued one way or the other. Thats also true.
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
hegyak
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 17:58 |
|
| I live here Три раза сломал клаву :) |
 |
Joined: Monday, 31 Mar 2008, 19:17 Posts: 6156 Location: Being smug somewhere fun
|
|
Me, I don't care about the creator of Minecraft. I care about how the legal system is being fucked with for money.
There is no honor amongst thieves and corporations.
_________________ The phrase "Login to http://www.clue.org and issue the GET command" springs to mind...  I moderated this forum.
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
Gryphes
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Monday, 23 Jul 2012, 22:00 |
|
| Forum ghost Местное привидение |
 |
Joined: Thursday, 22 Mar 2012, 21:57 Posts: 408 Location: Iceland
|
US is controlled by Illuminati and their henchmen so it's hard to climb up the ladder of the success. 
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
ChrisTX
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Tuesday, 24 Jul 2012, 05:26 |
|
| A+ |
 |
Joined: Wednesday, 26 Dec 2007, 00:42 Posts: 7317
|
Gryphes wrote: US is controlled by Illuminati and their henchmen so it's hard to climb up the ladder of the success.  The Illuminati hate Minecraft because you could build a world with it which the Illuminati wouldn't control... Seriously, this sentence is so stupid it's not even funny. Literally every country in the world has comparable laws and has granted equivalently questionable patents (not limited to software). This has absolutely nothing to do with the US. Also, if you really believe in the Illuminati you might stop reading InfoWars.com or similar turd, it is likely to cure this disease. hegyak wrote: I care about how the legal system is being fucked with for money. It isn't about honor. Legally viewed it is money they deserve of unlicensed usage of IP. If you can collect money using dubious patents and sueing everyone based on them, good for you. From a lawmaker's POV that is the case.
_________________ Game Industry Guardian (1K+).
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
Gryphes
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Tuesday, 24 Jul 2012, 07:32 |
|
| Forum ghost Местное привидение |
 |
Joined: Thursday, 22 Mar 2012, 21:57 Posts: 408 Location: Iceland
|
ChrisTX wrote: Gryphes wrote: US is controlled by Illuminati and their henchmen so it's hard to climb up the ladder of the success.  The Illuminati hate Minecraft because you could build a world with it which the Illuminati wouldn't control... Seriously, this sentence is so stupid it's not even funny. Literally every country in the world has comparable laws and has granted equivalently questionable patents (not limited to software). This has absolutely nothing to do with the US. Also, if you really believe in the Illuminati you might stop reading InfoWars.com or similar turd, it is likely to cure this disease. hegyak wrote: I care about how the legal system is being fucked with for money. It isn't about honor. Legally viewed it is money they deserve of unlicensed usage of IP. If you can collect money using dubious patents and sueing everyone based on them, good for you. From a lawmaker's POV that is the case. Seriously where the hell have you been? do you know how US dictates on other countries? politically, economically, culturally in every aspect US dictates every country either directly or indirectly. I am from Asia and here I see that all the time. and the Illuminati isn't some sorta of a cult. it's actually a some sorta of a secret society built by rich folks so they can control the society and people in every aspect as they want while protecting their business. that's the modern interpretation of the word Illuminati.
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
RessourectoR
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Tuesday, 24 Jul 2012, 09:09 |
|
| Administrator |
 |
Joined: Tuesday, 15 Nov 2005, 19:09 Posts: 9593 Location: here
|
|
Back on topic please.
_________________ ℝ.
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
Mr.Deviance
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Tuesday, 24 Jul 2012, 17:53 |
|
| Administrator |
 |
Joined: Thursday, 09 Oct 2003, 00:45 Posts: 2763 Location: Admin's watchtower
|
Gryphes wrote: Seriously where the hell have you been? do you know how US dictates on other countries? politically, economically, culturally in every aspect US dictates every country either directly or indirectly. I am from Asia and here I see that all the time. and the Illuminati isn't some sorta of a cult. it's actually a some sorta of a secret society built by rich folks so they can control the society and people in every aspect as they want while protecting their business. that's the modern interpretation of the word Illuminati. Don't become desperate with this subject. This is obviously not the right place where you should attempt to convince random people about theories that require lots of research and open mindedness towards things that tend to sound crazy and paranoid. Not sure if you realize it but the subject of illuminati has been effectively dragged and transformed into a public term that can be easily found in sci-fi games or movies. You can't talk about illuminati with random people and expect to be taken seriously anymore. The fact that you don't know this, shows me that you just talk about things you don't know, just for the sake of showing others that you've just came here from upper echelons... The worst possible thing you can try to do, is to attempt to "wake up" politically ignorant people, on a game piracy forum. Ignorance is bliss and your methods of presenting your opinions only make you look like a conspiracy freak, rather than a person that knows real facts. There are many categories of people that talk about illuminati. Most people talk about Illuminati because they've seen a few conspiracy youtube videos among which, most of them were probably Alex Jones and now they think they are no longer mere mortals. There are some people that talk about illuminati because they wish to appear sophisticated in front of others. Then there are those that analyze world wide politics and try to form a puzzle out of all the events that have happened, in order to predict what's going to happen! Illuminati is a name that's rapidly being adopted by the ignorant masses that are just willing to resume to believing a summed up description of who they are and what they want. If you want to discuss about various masonic lodges and their interests in controlling various media trusts and political parties, you should make a different topic because opening such debates here is just silly.
_________________ 
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
|
ChrisTX
|
Post subject: Re: Ok, WTF? Minecraft creator being sued Posted: Wednesday, 25 Jul 2012, 00:49 |
|
| A+ |
 |
Joined: Wednesday, 26 Dec 2007, 00:42 Posts: 7317
|
Hm, I've taken a quick look at that '067 patent. It's very widely applicable, but it explicitly describes processes that use a registration authority with license data obtained that is hashed and/or signed by a public key. I don't think any of the sued parties does this directly, but rather they're using the APIs of the respective marketplace. I don't know how good the chances for Uniloc to win this one are or based on what exactly they sued, but it sounds a little far fetched to me. Gryphes wrote: and the Illuminati isn't some sorta of a cult. it's actually a some sorta of a secret society built by rich folks so they can control the society and people in every aspect as they want while protecting their business. that's the modern interpretation of the word Illuminati. Just one question: If the Illuminati are so powerful and secret, and control the entire society, lawmaking and what else not... how come an average Joe like you knows of them? If they can influence literally everything, then keeping themselves secret should be easily done, right?
_________________ Game Industry Guardian (1K+).
|
|
| Top |
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests |
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
|
|